For being shot on the first morning by a trigger-happy psychopath who was coincidentally also mafia.
For shooting The Innkeeper for no in-game reason and publically admitting to it immediately.
For bringing the remnants of the townspeople together for the first sign of organised resistance, before dying in action.
For attacking Caius, all at once, with some success and much loss of secrecy.
For taking down the most dangerous mafioso, coming to exactly the right decisions about who to trust and for long hours of luckless lurking and shower inspecting.
Because no-one appeared to suspect him of being the werewolf, despite him admitting to having killed The Author, until he was randomly picked off by the mafioso The Undertaker.
For killing three townspeople, including an illuminatus attacking him, trying to kill a few more, and generally being the scariest mafioso.
For double killing with the evil mafioso The Faith Healer the first mafioso to go down, in the mafia raid in Caius.
For telling everyone that he had just seen The Lord of the Manor and The Farmer walking back to Trinity Hall together after the Caius mafia orgy. And being immediately shot, but too late.
For not shooting Matthew Johnson when he walked past, presumably in a fit of misplaced sentimentality.
For getting his gun stuck in his coat pocket in a l4m3 way when attacked by The Undertaker.
For living in the same house as a mafioso and proclaiming his innocence frequently and unconvincingly.
For doing her best against a very strong mafia.
For coshing his own mafia member, The Undertaker in order to gain access to the house of The General, in which Tom and Edith had a non-aggression pact. Sadly, Edith was out, but I was amused all the same.
For surviving, and killing 4 townspeople, despite being a generally lazy creature.
For, well, not being killed, despite the otherwise extremely high death rate among the sheep.Catherine Zentile also survived, amazingly, given that the rules stated she must not be shot. This might have been mostly because she lived in Girton in a no-kill zone.